Jesse (Alyssa Milano) is yet to find the right guy until she bumps into Ethan, a writer pushed to the edge of despair after having another novel rejected. For Jesse, the encounter offers more than a chance to inspire the artist in Ethan again. Moments after meeting the perfect guy for her, Jesse meets Mr. Perfect Troy, a confident advertising executive who makes almost every moment elegant and romantic. Hes perfect just like Ethan. Whats a girl to do?